How local SEO agencies find clients: start with low reviews and low ratings
Local SEO agencies find clients fastest by prospecting on a problem the owner can see: few reviews, a rating under 4 stars, or no working website. As of 5 Nov 2026, 34,975 of the 134,119 sellable US local businesses in the 67Leads warehouse (26%) have 9 reviews or fewer, and 608 are under 4 stars with 50 or more reviews.
Key numbers
- 34,9759 reviews or fewer
- 26%Share with 9 reviews or fewer
- 608Under 4 stars with 50+ reviews
- 24,572No website on the listing
Live from the 67Leads warehouse, computed (US Central) when this page was served. Sellable means graded as the trade, with a phone, opted-out businesses removed. Methodology.
Why prospect on a visible problem
A cold pitch for "local SEO" asks an owner to believe in something abstract. A pitch that says "you have 6 reviews and the three plumbers above you have 80 each" asks them to look at their own listing. The second one gets replies, because it is about them and they can check it in ten seconds.
Agencies that sell to local businesses already work this way. One poster in r/LeadGeneration put it in a single line: "HVAC companies under 10 reviews in mid sized cities" beats "contractors in texas" by a mile (r/LeadGeneration). Another reported that "segmenting leads by Google review count genuinely improved our reply rates" (r/coldemail).
The economics support the effort. The most common local SEO retainer band among agencies in Ahrefs' pricing survey was $500 to $1,000 a month (Ahrefs). One signed client can pay for a long time of prospecting.
Four problems to prospect on
1. Too few reviews
A business with a handful of reviews loses to competitors with dozens, however good its work is. Today 34,975 businesses in our warehouse have 9 reviews or fewer. That is the review-generation pitch: a simple system for asking every happy customer, and a short link that opens the review form. Our free Google review link generator makes that link, and is a useful thing to send a prospect for free.
2. A low rating with real volume
A business under 4 stars with 50 or more reviews has a reputation problem, not a visibility problem, and enough customers to fix it. There are 608 of those in our data. The pitch is review response and recovery: answer every review, fix what customers complain about, and ask the happy majority to say so.
Be careful with this one. Telling an owner their rating is bad is how the call ends. Lead with what you can do, and let them bring up the rating.
3. No website
A business with no website has nowhere to send the people who find its listing. 24,572 businesses in our data list no website. That pitch overlaps with web design, and our guide to finding businesses without websites covers it.
4. A website that does not load
7,662 businesses have a listed website that did not load when our crawler last checked. Their listing is sending customers to an error page. The website down checker lets you confirm it on the day you call.
Where each trade sits
Ratings and review counts differ by trade, which affects what "low" means. A trade where the median business has a handful of reviews is a different market from one where the median has a hundred. Here are the live figures from our Google ratings data study:
| Trade | Rated | Median rating | Under 4.0 | Perfect 5.0 | Median reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tree service companies | 39,135 | 5.0 | 7% | 55% | 12 |
| Plumbers | 12,966 | 4.9 | 4% | 35% | 70 |
| Roofing contractors | 11,387 | 4.9 | 3% | 42% | 41 |
| Dentists | 11,572 | 4.9 | 4% | 19% | 292 |
| HVAC contractors | 10,336 | 4.9 | 4% | 41% | 48 |
| Electricians | 8,796 | 4.9 | 8% | 41% | 21 |
| Med spas | 8,124 | 4.9 | 1% | 42% | 105 |
| Law firms | 7,497 | 4.9 | 4% | 30% | 67 |
| Cleaning companies | 6,264 | 4.9 | 3% | 42% | 45 |
| Insulation contractors | 3,915 | 4.9 | 9% | 47% | 12 |
| Pest control companies | 3,865 | 4.9 | 4% | 31% | 102 |
| Chiropractors | 3,620 | 4.9 | under 1% | 47% | 100 |
Compare your prospect against its own trade, not against everyone. The review score checker shows where one business's rating and review count rank against others in its trade and place, which makes a strong first line: "You are in the bottom quarter of plumbers in your city for reviews."
Building the prospect list
- Pick one trade and one metro. Local SEO is local; your case study from one plumber helps you sell to the next plumber in the same city.
- Filter for the problem you fix. For review generation: 9 or fewer reviews. For reputation: under 4 stars with 50+ reviews. For a site: no website, or one that does not load.
- Keep the businesses that can pay. A business with zero reviews may be too new or too small. A rating filter of 4.0 and up plus few reviews finds good businesses that are under-reviewed, the easiest yes.
- Get a contact. Email where the business publishes one and the mail server confirms it; the phone for the rest.
- Write one specific line per business. Their review count, their rating, a competitor's review count, their missing site.
In 67Leads this is one search, for example "dentists in Chicago with fewer than 10 reviews", with counts free and contacts masked until you export. The local SEO use case lists the filters local SEO agencies use and the live count for each.
The first email
Keep it short and about them:
- First line: the specific, checkable fact. "Your listing has 7 reviews; the two dentists above you in the map results have 140 and 95."
- Second line: what you would do, in one sentence.
- Third line: one question. "Worth a 10-minute call this week?"
- Footer: your name, company, postal address and a one-line opt-out, as CAN-SPAM requires (FTC).
Free cold email templates by trade give you a starting draft, and the subject line grader checks the subject.
What owners hear all day
Local business owners are pitched constantly, and SEO is one of the most pitched services. One service-business owner, quoted in r/coldemail, said: "We get 4-5 sales calls a day" (r/coldemail). The only way through is relevance. An email that could have been sent to any business will be treated like the other four.
Tools that help, for free
- Google review statistics by trade and state: the benchmark figures for your pitch deck.
- Review score checker: one business against its local peers.
- Google review link generator: a free gift that opens a conversation.
- Website down checker: proof for the broken-site pitch.
A note on ratings data
The ratings and review counts here are as they appeared on each business's public listing when we last collected it. A listing's rating is not an audit of the business, and a rating can change daily. Recheck the number on the day you send.
Questions
How do I find local SEO clients?
Prospect on a problem the owner can see: few reviews, a rating under 4 stars with plenty of reviews, no website, or a broken one. Filter one trade in one city, and lead every email with the specific fact about their listing.
What is a good number of Google reviews for a local business?
It depends on the trade and the city. Compare against the median for the same trade; the table above shows it, and the review score checker ranks one business against its local peers.
How much do local SEO agencies charge?
In Ahrefs' survey of SEO pricing, the most common local SEO retainer band was $500 to $1,000 a month.
Get 67 leads freeNo card. Search is free with contacts masked.