Insurance agents rated 4.5+ with few Google reviews in the US

Get 49 insurance agents in the US rated 4.5 or higher with 9 or fewer Google reviews and a phone number, out of the 427 67Leads lists there (11%). The first 67 leads of any list are free.

494.5★+, 9 or fewer reviews
11%Share of the list
44Rated 5.0
24List no website

Updated (the day rows in this list last changed). Counts as of 16 Nov 2026.

The first 5 on the list

CompanyCityRatingReviewsPhone
Royal Service Pro Contractor & Liability InsuranceBrooklyn, NY5.09+1347220****
Small Business Insurance Los AngelesLos Angeles, CA4.69+1213667****
NYC InsuranceNew York, NY5.07+1866227****
Roxbury Insurance ServicesLos Angeles, CA5.07+1310777****
Chirag Sharma, Agent - New York LifeRego Park, NY5.06+1718286****

Phones are masked. Get the list to export the full rows.

All 49 are free. Every new account gets its first 67 leads free, and this whole list fits inside them.

Get all 49 free

No card for the free 67. Credits are $6.70 per 1,000 leads, one time; a lead is charged once and re-downloads free. Or $67 a month for up to 500 new leads a day. Every lead you export is yours to keep.

What these numbers mean

11% of insurance agents in the US are rated 4.5 or higher with 9 or fewer reviews, below the 16% across every trade 67Leads lists.

The median business here has 2 reviews and the average rating is 5.0. A high rating from so few reviews is thin evidence, which is the opening: happy customers exist and few people can see them.

44 of the 49 (90%) are rated a perfect 5.0, so there is a good review to put in front of the next customer.

24 (49%) also list no website: one local-presence offer can cover both gaps.

Every business here has a phone number; 44 of the 49 (90%) have a local number rather than a toll-free one.

Ratings and review counts are as of the last refresh of each record, and can have moved since.

How to pitch them (general guidance)

Related: Every insurance agent in the US, rated or notInsurance agents in the US with no websiteInsurance agents in the US with 9 or fewer reviews

Free tools for this pitch

Review request generatorGoogle review QR code generatorReputation management pitch generator

Insurance agents by state

Texas (5)New York (13)California (24)Illinois (7)

Cities with the most insurance agents on this list

Los Angeles, CA (22)New York, NY (11)

Questions

How many insurance agents in the US are highly rated with few reviews?

49 of the 427 67Leads lists are rated 4.5 or higher, have 9 or fewer reviews and a phone number, counted from public business listings.

Is a high rating from a few reviews reliable?

Not on its own. A handful of reviews can swing a rating either way. That is why this list is a prospecting angle (good rating, little proof), not a ranking of quality.

Are the contacts shown?

Phones are masked on the page. Get the list to export phones and the emails we hold; the first 67 leads are free.

How much does it cost?

Searching is free with contacts masked and no daily cap, no account needed. Sign up and your first 67 leads export free, no card. Paying unlocks the rest. Plans: $6.70 for 1,000 credits, one time, no subscription; $67 a month for up to 500 new leads a day, no credits; $677 a year for up to 500 new leads a day, no credits, $127 less than paying monthly; $6,777 once for lifetime access, 500 new leads a day, limited to 100 seats. Every lead you export is yours to keep.