List of insurance agents in Columbus, OH with emails and phone numbers
Get 65 insurance agents in Columbus, OH: company name and phone number for all 65, 9 email addresses, 57 websites and 10 owner names. As of 17 Nov 2026, 67Leads lists 65 insurance agents in Columbus, OH. 9 (14%) have an email address read from the company's own website; none has been through the mail-server check yet.
See 5 real rows free
The top 5 insurance agents in Columbus, OH with the owner, phone and email in full, not masked. No account. 3 free samples a day, one trade and city each.
See 5 real rows freeLike what you see? These are 5 of the 65. Get all 65 free.
Get 67 leads freeAll 65 are free. Every new account gets its first 67 leads free, and this whole list fits inside them.
Get all 65 freeNo card for the free 67. Credits are $6.70 per 1,000 leads, one time; a lead is charged once and re-downloads free. Or $67 a month for up to 500 new leads a day. Every lead you export is yours to keep.
Updated (the day rows in this list last changed). Counts as of 17 Nov 2026.
What these numbers mean
Email coverage is 14%, in line with the 14% across the state.
8 have no website (12%), so most of this list has some web presence to research before you call.
Only 10 of these name an owner. Owner names are read from the company's own site rather than guessed, so coverage varies sharply by how much these businesses publish.
None of the addresses in Columbus, OH have been through the mail-server check yet, so every one is labelled unverified. Verification runs continuously and this figure moves.
ZIP codes with the most insurance agents
65 of the 65 insurance agents in Columbus, OH list a ZIP code, spread over 21 ZIP codes. The 5 busiest hold 60% of those; 43215 alone has 18.
| ZIP code | Insurance agents | Share |
|---|---|---|
| 43215 | 18 | 28% |
| 43214 | 10 | 15% |
| 43220 | 4 | 6% |
| 43229 | 4 | 6% |
| 43221 | 3 | 5% |
Sub-specialties by listing category
The largest listing category in Columbus is Insurance agency, at 74%; 4 categories appear in all.
No category's share in Columbus differs by 5 points or more from its share across Ohio.
| Listing category | Businesses | Share | Across Ohio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Insurance agency | 48 | 74% | 72% |
| Auto insurance agency | 15 | 23% | 22% |
| Home insurance agency | 1 | 2% | 1% |
| Insurance company | 1 | 2% | 1% |
The category is the one each business chose on its public listing.
Ratings
91% in Columbus are rated 4.5 stars or higher, against 92% across Ohio.
2 (3%) have no rating yet. Median reviews: 64 in Columbus, 65 across Ohio.
| Rating | Businesses | Share | Across Ohio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.8 to 5.0 | 50 | 77% | 79% |
| 4.5 to 4.7 | 9 | 14% | 12% |
| 4.0 to 4.4 | 2 | 3% | 3% |
| 3.0 to 3.9 | 1 | 2% | 1% |
| Under 3.0 | 1 | 2% | 1% |
| No rating yet | 2 | 3% | 3% |
A sample of insurance agents in Columbus, OH
| Company | Owner | Phone | City | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Compare Quote Insurance | Steve L. | +1888667**** | i***@comparequote.com | Columbus |
| Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio | John S. | +1614475**** | j***@slymaninsurancegroup.com | Columbus |
| John Dawson Associates | Kelly E. | +1614890**** | j***@johndawsoninsurance.com | Columbus |
| Nikki Ogunduyile - State Farm Insurance Agent | Nikki O. | +1614274**** | k****@nikkioinsurance.com | Columbus |
| Steve Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent | Steve R. | +1614457**** | — | Columbus |
| Adam Deel - State Farm Insurance Agent | Adam D. | +1614451**** | — | Columbus |
| Jonathan Yu - State Farm Insurance Agent | Jonathan Y. | +1614885**** | — | Columbus |
| Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent | Katie R. | +1614485**** | — | Columbus |
| Janna Bidlack - State Farm Insurance Agent | Janna B. | +1614764**** | — | Columbus |
| Andrea Taylor - State Farm Insurance Agent | Andrea T. | +1614855**** | — | Columbus |
| Globe Life American Income Division: Surace Smith & Partners Organization | — | +1614430**** | p***@ailife.com | Columbus |
| A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio | — | +1614221**** | q*****@callmitch.net | Columbus |
Contacts are masked until you export. Every email shown as verified was checked against the company's own mail server. Pricing · How the list is built
Get 67 leads freeNo card. Search is free with contacts masked. Opens a free search for the 65 insurance agents in Columbus, OH.
Free tools for this list
8 insurance agents in Columbus without a websitePreview the first 10Cold email templates for insurance agents
Guides for working this list
Selling to insurance agents: independent agencies, captive agents and ownersHow to verify a lead list before you send a single emailHow to find businesses without websites, and sell them a siteA cold-call script for web designers, with the objections and a voicemailHow to find the owner's name of a small local businessAll guidesLead tool alternativesFree tools
Questions
67Leads currently lists 65 insurance agents in Columbus, OH, of which 65 are graded as a core match for the trade.
9 of the 65 insurance agents in Columbus, OH have an email address on file, collected from the company's own website rather than guessed from a pattern.
10 of the 65 records in Columbus, OH include a named owner rather than only a company name.
Searching is free with contacts masked and no daily cap, no account needed. Sign up and your first 67 leads export free, no card. Paying unlocks the rest. Plans: $6.70 for 1,000 credits, one time, no subscription; $67 a month for up to 500 new leads a day, no credits; $677 a year for up to 500 new leads a day, no credits, $127 less than paying monthly; $6,777 once for lifetime access, 500 new leads a day, limited to 100 seats. Every lead you export is yours to keep.
Other trades in Columbus, OH
Auto repair shops in Columbus (135)Law firms in Columbus (108)Hair salons in Columbus (108)Gyms and fitness studios in Columbus (98)Real estate agents in Columbus (94)Accountants in Columbus (91)Dentists in Columbus (68)Veterinarians in Columbus (58)Roofing contractors in Columbus (53)Physical therapy clinics in Columbus (52)Cleaning companies in Columbus (51)Remodeling contractors in Columbus (50)Chiropractors in Columbus (48)Tree service companies in Columbus (48)Plumbers in Columbus (45)Moving companies in Columbus (43)Flooring contractors in Columbus (42)HVAC contractors in Columbus (40)Pest control companies in Columbus (39)Garage door companies in Columbus (38)Painting contractors in Columbus (36)Med spas in Columbus (33)Insulation contractors in Columbus (30)Electricians in Columbus (27)Fence contractors in Columbus (26)